Filipino Doctors, Sacrificial Lambs
03/29/2004 2:54:28 pm | 1190 reads | Category: 2nd Opinion
By now, everybody knows of Elmer Jacinto--the February medical boards topnotcher who publicly announced his plans to work in the US as a nurse. I was in Zamboanga City visiting my parents when that news broke out. A topnotcher from Lamitan, Basilan hit close to home and I showed the article to my brother. His only question was, "Why? Doesn't he have any offers?"I could only laugh and muster a short, "No, I don't think so."
Elmer Jacinto's situation and the reactions from various sectors are both funny and sad. I can only think of my brother's question and wonder: What can the country offer its best and brightest in the medical profession?
The short answer is none.
Unlike the legal profession, of which the medical profession is often compared to, there are no offers made to topnotchers. We've read news of bar topnotchers invited to join prestigious law firms. Top law graduates are employed even before the bar results are released, while some receive hefty signing bonuses from happy employers.
Medical board topnotchers are not that lucky. After a day or two in the light of fame, most fall back to the shadows of anonymity--their achievements a mere footnote in their résumé. We hardly remember the board topnotchers of the previous years. How many of them are practicing in the provinces, much less in the country? Can you just imagine the public outcry if we found out that only a few have stayed?
Therein lies the problem--the public outcry. Why is the public so pent up about doctors going abroad as doctors or nurses or caregivers or whatever? Because my short answer is not exactly correct. The country does have something to offer the graduates of the most noble profession: the poor and sick of the Philippines. Physicians, especially new ones, are expected to grab the opportunity to serve--for a pittance of a fee, or even for free.
I tried my hand in volunteerism once when I was "in between jobs"--or, in short, unemployed. Living a few blocks from the Malate Parish, I volunteered my services to their social services division for one day a week. I scoured the streets of Manila for jobs on Mondays to Thursdays, while I devoted Fridays to the urban poor of Malate. They gave me an old desk in the small office at the back of the church. The social worker announced my presence to community leaders, and, in no time, I was seeing 10-15 patients a session, which isn't exactly heavy.
It was a fun experience. A patient wanted me to give him a medical certificate stating that he should sleep on cement benches because it was good for his back. He was supposed to show this document to police officers of Luneta where he spent his nights. Another patient, a jolly 80/M, went to see me not for a check up but to show off that he was in perfect physical health. He would do jumping jacks and push ups in front of me.
It was also a time of desperation. A stroke patient, with half her body paralyzed, persistently showed up every Friday, limping her way through Manila traffic. She continued to have a BP of 200/140. Another patient had a resting systolic BP of 220-240. The list goes on. And I could do nothing but prescribe the cheapest anti-hypertensive. But they all had the same excuse: they didn't have the money to buy the drugs.
Not willing to lose a battle, I wrote the Parish for some support, financial or otherwise. I was asking for some drugs, about P800 worth, and a P500 money pool, in cases of emergency. And they replied that they can't contribute at the moment since they're finishing the wing for the missionaries, putting in a library and air-conditioning. I kid you not! I wrote a short letter to the city government, but they said all health support should go to the local health center.
One Sunday after mass, the parish social worker informed me that the Rotary Club of Manila was conducting an outreach program. I went with her and talked with the President of the club. They agreed with the whole package, insisting only that I submit proper accounting reports every month for their newsletter. I can't say it was smooth sailing from then on. It definitely helped me with some of my patients, monitoring for drug response rather than just looking on helplessly.
My experience is not unique. Volunteerism doesn't have to be so obvious. Surgeons forego professional fees after operations, internists accept P20 for consultation fees, pediatricians charge break-even for immunizations, and general practitioners accept eggs and chickens in exchange for services. These may be small acts, but they are by no means less heroic.
There are, of course, doctors who work with the poorest of the poor. Volunteer doctors to the war-torn parts of Mindanao would have different stories: their experience more colorful, their desperation more intense, their helplessness more personal. Their dedication is a strong testament to their character. These doctors who work with the poor often become poor themselves, and I have nothing but the utmost respect and admiration for them.
In all these cases, doctors are found in the frontlines of poverty. They work with almost no logistic and financial support. They carry the burden of salvation for their countrymen, with little or no compensation, with little or no thought of self. But the fact remains that mere presence can only do so much. What can a doctor give if he has nothing more than compassion and care? Is that really enough?
It's ludicrous how the public expects too much of a sacrifice from Filipino doctors, when it expects too little from its government officials. The fight for better health is a fight against poverty. It is not won by doctors becoming poor themselves, but by government officials becoming the leaders they need to be. Doctors do not make laws, allocate resources, handle budgets, public officials do. Doctors do not get kickbacks, destroy public trust, and plunder taxpayer's money, government scalawags do. So, when did doctors become sacrificial lambs for the ineptitudes of Philippine government?
The public flogs physicians, living on P10,000 a month, who pack up and go to the US as nurses, when they pay no mind to regional directors, earning P22,000 a month, who go abroad as tourists for weeks at a time. People look suspiciously at doctors driving a brand new Toyota Corolla after 5 years of practice, when they find nothing wrong with mayors sporting shiny Ford Expeditions after 6 months in office. If we should mourn for doctors who leave, let us grieve more for corrupt officials who stay. If we should complain of doctors who dream of decent living, let us condemn more those unscrupulous government employees who lead obscene lives. Wounded souls search for healing in other countries, but there is no cure for callous hearts.
A mayor once asked me to join a free medical mission he sponsored. I humbly asked if there was any payment involved for my services. "Ah, eh, wala. Pero libre naman ang pagkain. Tapos ipapahiram ko naman yung Pajero ko at isa kong Starex para libre na rin yung transpo."
I wanted to bitch-slap him until his lips bled.
---------------------
Michael Hussin B. Muin, M.D. is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Pinoy.MD - The Website for Filipino Doctors. He is a professor of Clinical Anatomy and Medical Informatics in Pangasinan.
Discuss this article at the Pinoy.MD Articles area of the Pinoy.MD Community Board.
| Poster | Thread |
|---|---|
| eyedoc | Posted: 03/29/2004 4:16 Updated: 03/29/2004 4:16 |
Consultant ![]() ![]() Joined: 11/07/2003 From: Manila Posts: 57 |
Very well said, Mike.
|
| docjoy62 | Posted: 03/30/2004 1:05 Updated: 03/30/2004 1:05 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 03/25/2004 From: Bacolod City, Philippines Posts: 6 |
Wow!
That was accurately & very well-written there Mike...I hope you can publish this in the national newspaper! The whole country, especially the gov't officials should read this, hehe! ![]() |
| stethacp | Posted: 03/30/2004 8:22 Updated: 03/30/2004 8:22 |
Training Officer ![]() ![]() Joined: 10/07/2003 From: Las Pinas City Posts: 105 |
Naiyak naman ako.... exactly my sentiments. ![]() |
| drglenn | Posted: 03/30/2004 5:01 Updated: 05/12/2004 1:52 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 01/13/2004 From: Posts: 7 |
I believe you just expressed my own sentiments about the current state of medical practice in the country, only more eloquently. But the current gloom and a general sense of hopelessness among Pinoy docs is not unique to us. Read Richard Smith's article (my own idol, who's currently the editor-in-chief of the British Medical Journal) on "Why are doctors unhappy?"
Why are doctors unhappy?" But then be inspired by his subsequent article on "Thoughts for new medical students at a new medical school" http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/reprint/327/7429/1430.pdf |
| rsbarbamd | Posted: 03/31/2004 3:36 Updated: 03/31/2004 3:36 |
Chief of Clinics ![]() ![]() Joined: 10/27/2003 From: Florida Posts: 182 |
Bravo Mike !!!
Wherever you go, most doctors are unhappy ! There are only few contented on what they earn and what they have become. Even here in US, most MD's think that they are overworked and undersupported and the worst part is that they are being dictated by the health system...lawyers, insurances etc... you will see legal cases filed by the patient against the doctors left and right and you cant help but sympathize with the doctors who did their best but unfortunately became victims of murphy's law. Gone were the days when doctors were treated like GODS! Looking back, somewhere along the way...the ethics of medical profession were breached and highly politicized by officers of different societies who could have maintained the integrity of the medical profession. I believe that in order to help others we should help ourselves first. How can we poor doctors extend our utmost help when we and our family can barely survive. I don't know what to think anymore, but i am still hoping that something good will happen to our country and that is why i am coming back! |
| sunshine | Posted: 04/03/2004 11:32 Updated: 04/03/2004 11:32 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 01/27/2004 From: Posts: 12 |
very well said mike. I for one is among new batch of confused internist in limbo I recently passed the diplomate board, but I'm really frustrated in a dusky horizon ahead... mahirap maging doctor tapos wala pala masyado opportunities and to top that Lalaitin ka lang ng isang reporter tulad ni KORINA SANCHEZ.... wag iboto boyfriend nya ha Mar Roxas
|
| rsbarbamd | Posted: 04/05/2004 1:02 Updated: 04/05/2004 1:04 |
Chief of Clinics ![]() ![]() Joined: 10/27/2003 From: Florida Posts: 182 |
Sunshine,
I agree with you. Korina Sanchez is very unprofessional kasi she can't separate her subjective emotional frustrations... she was dumped by a makati med doctor and perhaps she was traumatized and since then she is on the loose and started her vendetta against men in whites. But the one who helped her mother was a filipino doctor pa rin. Don't worry if Mar Roxas will dump her, bka she will turn to politicians instead of the poor doctors.. ![]() |
| TopMedic | Posted: 04/06/2004 12:02 Updated: 04/06/2004 12:02 |
Training Officer ![]() ![]() Joined: 10/28/2003 From: Lake in the Hills IL Posts: 144 |
Very well said, Mike.
![]() |
| lungdoc | Posted: 04/06/2004 7:30 Updated: 04/06/2004 7:30 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 11/01/2003 From: Posts: 8 |
the story of dr. elmer jacinto is just the reality for doctors now... i hope ABS-CBN and Inquirer will publish the stories of Medical Specialists (Pulmonologists / Cardiologists / Radiologists) who are getting out of the country as nurses (im sure they are more interesting than the story of Dr. Jacinto)... i know quite a few friends and they will be taking the june board exam for nurses...
![]() |
| tortuga | Posted: 04/07/2004 12:56 Updated: 04/07/2004 12:56 |
Consultant ![]() ![]() Joined: 02/19/2004 From: Posts: 64 |
doctors work abroad as nurses
The article above was posted 2 months ago. It's very sad when even the specialists are going into Nursing. You think that they would be doing better. I allowed my wife to come back to the Phil. to take Nursing as second course (She was a Med. Tech.) and a lot of students now are second-coursers. Maybe the only institutions thriving now are Nursing schools. |
| doclils | Posted: 04/11/2004 10:00 Updated: 04/11/2004 10:00 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 04/11/2004 From: Quezon City Posts: 3 |
Mike,
Bravo for a well written article, I have been a regular visitor of this website but it is only now that I found time to register, I forwarded your article to Mr. Boo Chanco (of Philippine Star) because I feel that public awareness must be increased on the true conditions of Filipino Doctors.... He will use the said aticle on his column on Wednesday (April 14, 2004) I hope it's okay with you.... |
| cruzin | Posted: 04/12/2004 7:46 Updated: 04/12/2004 7:49 |
Resident ![]() ![]() Joined: 04/12/2004 From: Pasig City, Philippines Posts: 3 |
A very relevant article written by my classmate from UPCM Class 1998.
Our class had the most number of graduates staying since graduation compared with batches from 1999+ However, we are faced with harsh realities of trying to set up a practice and for some like the author and me are stonewalled by politics and crab mentality... There is no place for idealism in the Philippines right now. Its either you accept your fate and subsist on a meager salary or brown nose with the powers that be. Some senior consultants would even say to me - "Welcome to the Real World!". The things about compassion and idealism you learn in college disappears when you try to live it in Philippine Society. I have a bunch of classmates who are now studying to become nurses. Graduates from UP. I don't blame them. As for the author and me, we are planning to go to the States as doctors in the hope of finding light in our stalled medical career... Cruzin MD, Batch 98 |






That was accurately & very well-written there Mike...I hope you can publish this in the national newspaper! The whole country, especially the gov't officials should read this, hehe! 








